Mouse Island: A Historical Gem for Sale
COLUMBUS, Ohio – A unique opportunity has arisen for anyone with a taste for history and a love for nature. Nestled in the shimmering waters of Lake Erie, Mouse Island is now on the market, presenting a rare chance for prospective buyers to own a piece of Americana once connected to a U.S. President.
A Brief Overview of Mouse Island
Located just north of the Catawba peninsula and flanked by Kelleys Island and Put-in-Bay, Mouse Island encompasses seven acres of mature woodlands and rocky shores, all listed for a cool $5 million. The island is described as the “Hawaii of Ohio,” thanks to its lush landscape and serene environment.
Historical Significance
Mouse Island’s charm is steeped in history, previously owned by none other than President Rutherford B. Hayes, the 19th President of the United States. Hayes acquired the island on August 1, 1873, just a few years prior to his presidential election in 1877. His original co-owners included notable figures like Civil War general Ralph Buckland and local physician L. Q. Rawson.
Presidential Ownership
Two years into his presidency, Hayes became the sole owner of the island, negotiating a buyout of Rawson’s share and trading land in Nebraska for Buckland’s stake. The Hayes family cherished this property for over 90 years, until its sale in 1966. Today, it remains privately owned but continues to attract interest due to its rich heritage.
Life on Mouse Island
An excerpt from a letter written by Webb Cook Hayes, Rutherford’s son, paints a vivid picture of life on the island during the Victorian era. The letter recounts a week of camping filled with activities like bathing, boating, and fishing, reflecting the idyllic lifestyle enjoyed by those who visited.
This glimpse into the past highlights the island’s allure, demonstrating how it was once a popular retreat for social gatherings, akin to the luxurious getaways found in today’s vacation spots.
Current Usage and Potential
Mouse Island is zoned for private use and is only accessible by boat, making it an ideal sanctuary for those seeking solitude or a getaway from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. The real estate listing suggests various potential uses, from a luxury vacation compound to an off-grid retreat, making it not just a property but a blank canvas for the right buyer.
Exploring the Island
Access to the island itself is restricted, but a video titled “Exploring Mouse Island Ruins Port Clinton, Ohio” provides a glimpse of its grounds. Viewers can see remnants of past structures, including what remains of a stone fireplace, a testament to the craft and materials that went into building on the island.
Comparison to Other Islands
Not far from this famed isle lies Onion Island, previously listed for sale at $1.59 million. Unlike Mouse Island’s rich presidential connection, Onion Island had associations with World War I ace Captain Eddie Rickenbacker. However, the latter’s status has since faded, making Mouse Island a more intriguing buy for history enthusiasts and nature lovers alike.
The Perfect Escape
Mouse Island’s unique combination of history and natural beauty makes it an exceptional investment. For many, the prospect of owning a private island with such a storied past is a dream come true. Whether it’s creating a luxurious escape or simply maintaining a slice of history, this tiny island presents an unparalleled opportunity in the heart of Ohio’s lake country.