A Private Island for Sale: A Curious Listing on Grass Lake
A recent real estate listing has captured the attention of many looking for a unique getaway—a “private island” on Grass Lake, near the far north suburban Antioch, Illinois. With a price tag of $200,000, this property is touted as a “rare gem on the legendary Chain O’ Lakes.” But as the saying goes, if something seems too good to be true, it probably is.
A Surprising Surge in Interest
The listing quickly became a topic of discussion online, racking up over 59,000 views on Zillow and generating considerable chatter on Facebook. This spike in interest hints at a common dream among many: owning a little slice of paradise, where one can retreat from the chaos of everyday life. However, prospective buyers should be cautious.
The Reality of the Property
Described optimistically as a “secluded retreat” and a “one-of-a-kind vacation rental,” the reality is a bit less glamorous. According to Rob Hardman, owner of the neighboring Blarney Island, the property is actually “a hype job of a dilapidated property that has been unused for decades.” The island not only suffers from neglect but is also showing signs of sinking.
The Technical Aspects
Spanning 1.22 acres, the island has not been well-maintained, leaving behind a deteriorating seawall that poses a significant risk. Joe Keller, the executive director of the Fox Waterway Agency, emphasized that the island has become endangered due to this neglected seawall, which has failed and threatens the integrity of the land. Any potential buyer will face the challenge of not only revitalizing the island but also investing in protective measures to stabilize the shoreline. Furthermore, they’ll need permits from the Army Corps of Engineers before commencing any work.
Unpacking the Listings and Claims
Originally listed in early June for $250,000, the price was later reduced. The current listing encompasses six lots owned by Kim Renner, who acquired them for $50,000 in 2020. Renner is reportedly moving out of state, enabling this unusual opportunity. Brett Larson, the property’s listing agent, believes that despite the work required, the area is rapidly gaining value, making it a potentially wise investment.
The Condition of the Property
However, Hardman highlights critical drawbacks that buyers should consider: the absence of power, water, or a septic system, in addition to the fact that the land has endured two recent fires. While the original listing boasted the availability of electricity, its current status remains uncertain.
A Historical Perspective
The island has a colorful history. According to local boat captain Dan Shaughnessy, it was once part of a larger peninsula, reshaped by the meandering Fox River over time. The island was even a recreational retreat for three Polish ironworkers from Chicago, who enjoyed it with their families. This rich past contrasts sharply with the property’s current state, leaving many questioning its value.
Social Media Reactions
The bid for this quirky island hasn’t come without skepticism. Comments on social media evoke mixed feelings, with some users humorously suggesting, “Pull the cork and let it sink.” Such remarks reflect a significant divide between those enchanted by the idea of island life and those aware of the property’s grim realities.
The Takeaway
As intrigue surrounds this unusual listing, potential buyers are reminded to weigh the allure of owning a private island against the practical challenges ahead. With its blend of charm and caution, this property serves as a fascinating case study in the realm of real estate, prompting us all to consider: What truly makes a dream property?